The Follower

Gerry Conlon facing his father Giuseppe — In the Name of the Father (1993)

I was a nuisance, tripping, falling,
Yapping always. But today
It is my father who keeps stumbling
Behind me, and will not go away.
— Seamus Heaney, “Follower”

Seamus Heaney’s enormous genius lay in his ability to access the poeticism of ordinary life–often he talks about the lyric nature of our emotional life, how the natural world is saturated with meaning, how grief is commuted by beauty. His poem, The Follower is both a kind lamentation of a son for his Father. But the poem is more than pretty–it is about truth known to men. That we walk in our Father’s shadow ceaselessly, often angrily and even blindly before they die.

Trauma–itself a Shakespearean phenomena-walks out onto its own stage slowly. Smart therapists do not push when it comes to trauma-that work ought to be titrated—taken slowly, walked out—not expurgated.

In his poem, the boy stumbles in his father's wake and falls, again and again, on the polished sod. We fall into the traps of our fathers first — their furrows become our furrows, their tempers our tempers, their silences ours. Then the positions turn: it is the father who keeps stumbling behind the grown man, and will not go away. And the follower does not wait outside the door. They follow us all the way — even here, even to healing. The promise is sold everywhere: scream it out and be rid of him. Heaney knew better. No one is rid of him. The question the poem leaves is whether a man learns to walk with what follows him, slowly, instead of paying to pretend it can be torn out–which can happen when people are not trained to deal with trauma.

Let me be generous first, because the hunger underneath this is real. Men are given almost no place where feeling is allowed without apology. A voice that says — bring it here, all of it, we can hold it — answers something genuine. The tears are not fake. Breathwork does move things in the body; it is not theatre in the body, whatever theatre surrounds it. And for some man, it may be the first time he has ever cried in front of another person and not been left alone with it. That is not nothing. It may be a door.

My worry is not the feeling. It is the framing. Feeling produced on cue, in company, with witnesses, runs a risk: what is performed begins to be displayed rather than felt, and a thing that can be summoned to order starts to be sold as an unearthing. A door is not the house. Catharsis is a moment; change is a practice. When the moment is sold as the change, a man goes home lit up — and lands, within days, in exactly the same life, now doubting himself for failing to stay transformed.

And I have to be careful, and plain, about the harder end of this world: the rooms where they hold a man down — restrain him, physically — so that he can fight his way through his trauma. Some of the people who do this mean well, and will tell you it is consented to and contained. I cannot get past one thing. For a man whose wound involves helplessness, being held down risks rehearsing the wound itself. Consent handed over in an hour, to a stranger's method, is thin consent. Whatever needs to come out of a person has to come out under his own power, or it is not his.

If a man screams, the scream is his, and it matters. My objection was never to the scream. If you scream, let it be your scream — at your volume, ending when you end it. Control the scream. Don't let it be conducted, restrained, or applauded into something it isn't.

Change is slow and unglamorous. It happens mostly alone, on ordinary Tuesdays, and it does not photograph.

So: if it opens something, honour what you felt — it was yours. Then do the slow work that lets it stay true. The quiet room is not in competition with the fire. It is where the fire should lead back to.

— Llewelyn-Roen Prowe

Llewelyn-Roen Prowe

Llewelyn-Roen Prowe is an author, former strategic consultant, and psychotherapist living and working in rural Vermont.

http://www.snowcreek.info
Next
Next

The Old Books Are Patient